|
|
Tycho Brahe, Johannes Kepler and Planetary
Motion(2/2)
|
Epitome of Copernican Astronomy
was read by astronomers throughout Europe, and following
Kepler's death it was the main vehicle for spreading
Kepler's ideas. Between 1630 and 1650, it was the most
widely used astronomy textbook, winning many converts to
ellipse-based astronomy.[52]
However, few adopted his ideas on the physical basis for
celestial motions. In the late 17th century, a number of
physical astronomy theories drawing from Kepler's
work—notably those of
Giovanni Alfonso Borelli and
Robert Hooke—began to incorporate attractive forces
(though not the quasi-spiritual motive species
postulated by Kepler) and the
Cartesian
concept of
inertia. This culminated in
Isaac Newton's
Principia Mathematica (1687), in which Newton
derived Kepler's laws of planetary motion from a
force-based theory of
universal gravitation.[72] |
Among many other harmonies, Kepler
articulated what came to be known as the
third law of planetary motion. He then tried many
combinations until he discovered that (approximately) "The
square of the periodic times are to each other as the
cubes of the mean distances." However, the wider
significance for planetary dynamics of this purely
kinematical law was not realized until the 1660s. For
when conjoined with
Christian Huygens' newly discovered law of
centrifugal force it enabled
Isaac Newton,
Edmund Halley and perhaps
Christopher Wren
and
Robert Hooke to demonstrate independently that the
presumed gravitational attraction between the Sun and
its planets decreased with the square of the distance
between them.[59]
This refuted the traditional assumption of scholastic
physics that the power of gravitational attraction
remained constant with distance whenever it applied
between two bodies, such as was assumed by Kepler and
also by Galileo in his mistaken universal law that
gravitational fall is uniformly accelerated, and also by
Galileo's student Borrelli in his 1666 celestial
mechanics.[60] |
In 1623, Kepler at last completed the
Rudolphine Tables,
which at the time was considered his major work.
However, due to the publishing requirements of the
emperor and negotiations with
Tycho Brahe's heir, it would not be printed until
1627. In the meantime religious tension—the root of the
ongoing
Thirty Years'
War—once again put Kepler and his family in
jeopardy. In 1625, agents of the
Catholic Counter-Reformation placed most of Kepler's
library under seal, and in 1626 the city of Linz was
besieged. Kepler moved to
Ulm, where he arranged for the printing of the
Tables at his own expense.[61]
Star tables had been produced for many
centuries and were used to establish the position of the
planets relative to the fixed stars (particularly the
twelve constellations used in
astrology) on a specific date in order to construct
horoscopes. In 1551, following the publication of
De revolutionibus orbium coelestium by
Nicholas Copernicus,
Erasmus Reinhold
produced the
Prussian Tables based on a heliocentric model of the
solar system, but these were no more accurate than the
earlier tables. They contain positions for the 1,006
stars measured by
Tycho Brahe, and 400 and more stars from
Ptolemy and
Johann Bayer, with
directions and tables for locating the
planets of the
solar system. The tables included many function
tables of
logarithms and antilogarithms, and instructive
examples for computing planetary positions.
In 1628, following the military successes
of the
Emperor Ferdinand's armies under
General Wallenstein, Kepler became an official
adviser to Wallenstein. Though not the general's court
astrologer per se, Kepler provided astronomical
calculations for Wallenstein's astrologers and
occasionally wrote horoscopes himself. In his final
years, Kepler spent much of his time traveling, from the
imperial court in Prague to Linz and Ulm to a temporary
home in
Sagan, and finally to
Regensburg. Soon after arriving in Regensburg,
Kepler fell ill. He died on November 15, 1630, and was
buried there; his burial site was lost after the Swedish
army destroyed the churchyard.[62] |
|
 |
Johannes Kepler silver commemorative coin |
The Sleepwalkers:
A History of Man's Changing Vision of the Universe
is a 1959 book by
Arthur Koestler,
and one of the main accounts of the history of
cosmology and
astronomy in the
Western World, beginning in ancient
Mesopotamia and ending with
Isaac Newton. |
Carved Stone Balls
Of the 387 known carved stone
balls, 375 are about 70 mm in diameter about the size of
tennis balls. |
Pythagorean_tuning has been documented as
long ago as 1800 B.C. in Babylonian texts.[1]
It is the oldest way of tuning the 12-note
chromatic scale. Pythagorean tuning is based on a
stack of intervals, each tuned in the ratio 3:2, the
next simplest ratio after 2:1, which is considered to
yield the same note. For instance, the A is tuned such
that the frequency ratio of A and D is 3:2 — if D is
tuned to 288
Hz, then the A is tuned to 432 Hz. The E above A is
also tuned in the ratio 3:2 — with the A at 432 Hz, this
puts the E at 648 Hz. One of Pythagoras'
favorite and most "Sacred Numbers" was 432000, a
"harmonic" of 4320. |
|
|
|
|
 |
In three dimensions there are just
five regular polyhedra.
- Tetrahedron - made of 4 equilateral
triangles
- Cube - made of 6 squares
- Octahedron - made of 8 equilateral
triangles
- Dodecahedron - made of 12 regular
pentagons
- Icosahedron - made of 20 equilateral
triangles
|
planetary spheres
|
In his Mysterium Cosmographicum, where Kelar
constructed a model of the solar system in which the distances
of the planetary orbits were physically expressed by the nesting
of these five regular solids. |
THE GEOMETRY OF CREATION
Plato's Timaeus and the Regular Polyhedra by Nicholas Gier and
Gail Adele
"Finally, the most amazing vindication of Plato has come from
recent surveys of the universe that indicate that the universe
may indeed be a dodecahedron, whose reflecting pentagonal faces
give the illusion of an infinite universe when in fact it is
finite." |
Kepler and the Music of the Spheres by David
Plant @
skyscript.co.uk |
Pauli on conflict between Kepler and Flood @ psychovision.ch |
Kepler Quotes by todayinsci.com
Dictionary of Science Quotations |
Kepler Tour and
Tycho
Brae Tour by Sachiko Kusukawa, Adam Mosley and the
University of Cambridge. |
Sacred
Theory: Carved Stone Balls @prehistoric-technology.com |
Galileo Galilei @ spaceandmotion.com |
Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo & Newton @ uwgb.edu/ |
The Personal Lives and Philosophies of
Copernicus, Kepler, Galileo, Newton and Einstein
@catholicintl.com |
Isaac
Newton: Overview
Isaac
Newton: Alchemist |
|
|
 |
Johannes Kepler |
If this [the
Mysterium cosmographicum] is published, others will
perhaps make discoveries I might have reserved for
myself. But we are all ephemeral creatures (and none
more so than I). I have, therefore, for the Glory of
God, who wants to be recognized from the book of
Nature, that these things may be published as
quickly as possible. The more others build on my
work the happier I shall be.
— Johannes Kepler
[Letter to Michael Maestlin (3 Oct 1595)]
|
|
His first publication in 1597 was called
Mysterium Cosmographicum (literally, the Cosmic Mystery).
Mysterium, Kepler attempted to show that planetary orbits
were arranged in accordance with the regular, or Platonic
polyhedra . In this way, for example, Kepler argued that the
ratio of orbital radii for Venus and Mercury was the same, or
nearly so, as the ratio of the radii for the circumscribed and
inscribed spheres of an octahedron.
As he indicated in the title, Kepler thought
he had revealed God’s geometrical plan for the universe. His
subsequent main astronomical works were in some sense only
further developments of it, concerned with finding more precise
inner and outer dimensions for the spheres by calculating the
eccentricities of the planetary orbits within it. In 1621 Kepler
published an expanded second edition of Mysterium, half
as long again as the first, detailing in footnotes the
corrections and improvements he had achieved in the 25 years
since its first publication.
Through their letters, Tycho and Kepler
discussed a broad range of astronomical problems, dwelling on
lunar phenomena and Copernican theory (particularly its
theological viability). But without the significantly more
accurate data of Tycho's observatory, Kepler had no way to
address many of these issues.
Instead, Keplar turned his attention to chronology and
"harmony," the numerological relationships among music,
mathematics and the physical world, and their astrological
consequences. By assuming the Earth to possess a soul (a
property he would later invoke to explain how the sun causes the
motion of planets), he established a speculative system
connecting astrological aspects and astronomical distances to
weather and other earthly phenomena.
Mysterium Cosmographicum: the cosmic mystery |
Johannes Kepler
believed in Copernicus’ picture. Raised in the Greek
geometric tradition, he believed God must have had some
geometric reason for placing the six planets at the
particular distances from the sun that they occupied. He
thought of their orbits as being on spheres, one inside
the other. One day, he suddenly remembered that there
were just five perfect Platonic solids, and this gave a
reason for there being six planets - the orbit spheres
were maybe just such that between two successive ones a
perfect solid would just fit. He convinced himself that,
given the uncertainties of observation at the time, this
picture might be the right one. |
 |
 |
The 5
solids as drawn in Kepler's Mysterium Cosmographicum. |
A platonic solid (also called regular
polyhedra or Pythagorean solid) is a convex polyhedron
whose vertices and faces are all of the same
type. There are only five regular figures
have many remarkable properties; All of their
vertices lie on a sphere. They all have equal
edges, equal faces, and equal angles.
That these solids ordered our solar system was Keplar's great initial insight, which
informed and supported his later breakthrough discoveries,
accords much to geometry as a principle which orders the
universe and all its creatures. Although best known as
Platonic solids their importance in ordering the
universe was first brought to the attention by Pythagoras
[570-c. 495 BC]
whose
education was distinguished by decades of study in Egypt
and other ancient centers of learning and initiation.
|
|
Some of the greatest achievements of
Plato's Academy came in the areas of mathematics
and astronomy. Heraclides Ponticus discovered the
axial revolution of the earth and the revolution of
Venus and Mercury around the sun. Eudoxus gave us
the theory of proportion, the method of exhaustion, and
the concentric spheres of the Ptolemaic cosmology.
Theaetetus was the inventor of solid geometry and
the general theory of incommensurables. He also
constructed the regular polyhedra, demonstrated that
each of them could be inscribed in a sphere, and proved
that there could only be five. During a trip to Sicily
in 367 B.C.E., Plato may have first learned of the
regular polyhedra from Archytas, the last of the
Pythagoreans. In the Timaeus Plato used the
regular polyhedra as the basic elements of the universe.
As a brilliant anticipation of modern
physics, the "receptacle" of the Timaeus is combination
of space, matter, and energy. Classical physics followed
the Greek atomists in separating matter and energy, but
modern physics of the 20th century has had to return to the inseparability first
proposed by Plato. |
|
Kepler's geometric scheme for
the relative orbits of the planets in our
visible solar system which eventually led to his
formulation of the Laws of Planetary motion.
Kepler's first book; The Cosmic Mystery argued
that the distances of the planets from the Sun
in the Copernican system were determined by the
five regular solids, if one supposed that a
planet's orbit was circumscribed about one solid
and inscribed in another. Except for Mercury,
Kepler's construction produced remarkably
accurate results.
Tycho Brae impressed with Kepler's talent and
insight as a mathemetician asked Kepler to
calculate new orbits for the planets from
Tycho's observations. Kepler moved to Prague in
1600. |
According to Keplar, the orbits of
the six planets known at the time—Mercury, Venus, Earth,
Mars, Jupiter and Saturn—could be arranged in spheres
nested around the five Platonic solids: octahedron,
icosahedron, dodecahedron, tetrahedron and cube. The Platonic polyhedra arranged in this
order, coinciding circumspheres for a given polyhedron and
inspheres for the next polyhedron gave a fair approximation for
the relative sizes of planetary orbits around the Sun. Kepler
never rejected this model but his strive for increased accuracy
and explanations for variances would occupy his career.
Kepler was convinced
"that the
geometrical things have provided the Creator with the
model for decorating the whole world."
In the tradition of the
legendary Greek philosopher Pythagoras (6th century BC),
Kepler did not view science and spirituality as mutually
exclusive, he saw his work reconciling the emerging
vision of a Sun-centred planetary system with the
ancient Pythagorean concept of armonia, or
universal harmony.
|
Pythagoras discovered that the pitch of
a musical note depends upon the length of the string which
produces it. This allowed him to correlate the intervals of the
musical scale with simple numerical ratios. When a musician
plays a string stopped exactly half-way along its length an
octave is produced. The octave has the same quality of sound as
the note produced by the unstopped string but, as it vibrates at
twice the frequency, it is heard at a higher pitch. The
mathematical relationship between the keynote and its octave is
expressed as a 'frequency ratio' of 1:2. In every type of
musical scale, the notes progress in a series of intervals from
a keynote to the octave above or below. Notes separated by
intervals of a perfect fifth (ratio 2:3) and a perfect fourth
(3:4) have always been the most important 'consonances' in
western music. In recognizing these ratios, Pythagoras had
discovered the mathematical basis of musical harmony.
The musicologist Joscelyn Godwin comments,
"...the celestial harmony of the solar system... is of a
scope and harmonic complexity that no single approach can
exhaust. The nearest one can come to understanding it as a whole
is to consider some great musical work and think of the variety
of analytical approaches that could be made to it, none of them
embracing anything like the whole."
In Harmony, Keplar attempted to explain the
proportions of the natural world—particularly the astronomical
and astrological aspects—in terms of music. The central set of
"harmonies" was the musica universalis or "music of the
spheres," which had been studied by Pythagoras, Ptolemy
and many others before Kepler. Soon after publishing Harmonices Mundi, Kepler was embroiled in a
celebrated exchange
with Robert Fludd, who had recently published his own
harmonic theory. Their ideas continue to resonate in the 21st
century as the call grows louder for a recognition of the value
of their sort of alchemical or intuitive science that is capable
ofn embracing the concept of multiple levels of soul and its
calling card of synchronicity.
"Geometry is
unique and eternal, a reflection from the mind
of God. That mankind shares in it is because man
is an image of God." |
---Johannes Kepler |
|
4000 year old
Carved Stone Balls |
with symmetrical
form of the five Platonic solids |
|
 |
Five of nearly 400 Neolithic Stone Balls (ca. 2,000 BCE)
now kept at Ashmolean Museum at
Oxford University. |
These rounded stones with
regularly spaced bumps are from largely from Northeast Scotland.
Some degree a high level of craftsmanship and their
use is not known and it may have been oracular or as
venerated ritual art objects. High points of each bump mark the vertices of each of
the regular polyhedra. The stone balls also appear to
demonstrate the duals of three of the regular polyhedra.
The lack of balls found in graves may indicate that they
were not considered to belong to individuals.
'Sink
stones' found in Denmark and Ireland have some slight
similarities, these artifacts being used in conjunction
with fishing nets. |
1600: Tycho hires Kepler
By 1599, however, Keplar again felt his work
limited by the inaccuracy of available data—just as growing
religious tension was also threatening his continued employment
in Graz. Because of his talent as a mathematician, displayed in
this volume, Kepler was invited by Tycho Brahe to Prague to
become his assistant and calculate new orbits for the planets
from Tycho's observations in December of that year. Tycho invited Kepler to visit
him in Prague; on January 1, 1600 (before he even received the
invitation), Kepler set off in the hopes that Tycho's patronage
could solve his philosophical problems as well as his social and
financial ones.
On August 2, 1600, after refusing to convert
to Catholicism, Kepler and his family were banished from Graz.
Several months later, Kepler returned, now with the rest of his
household, to Prague. Through most of 1601, he was supported
directly by Tycho, who assigned him to analyzing planetary
observations and writing a tract against Tycho's deceased rival,
Ursus. In September, Tycho secured him a commission as a
collaborator on the new project he had proposed to the emperor:
the Rudolphine Tables that should replace the Prutenic Tables of Erasmus Reinhold.
Two days after Tycho's unexpected death on
October 24, 1601, Kepler was appointed his successor as imperial
mathematician with the responsibility to complete his unfinished
work. The next 11 years as imperial mathematician, the most
prestigious appointment in mathematics in Europe would be the
most productive of his life until, in 1612, Emperor Rudolph II
was deposed
Kepler revealed the discovery of his first two
laws of planetary motion in his Astronomia Nova,
published in 1609. The announcement of his third law was not
made until 1618.
Kepler's Three Laws of Planetary Motion |
- I The planets move in elliptical orbits
with the sun at a focus.
- II In their orbits around the sun, the
planets sweep out equal areas in equal times.

- III The squares of the times to complete
one orbit are proportional to the cubes of the average
distances from the sun.
|
These are the laws that Newton was able to use
to establish universal gravitation.
"And if you want the exact
moment in time, it was conceived mentally on 8th
March in this year one thousand six hundred and
eighteen, but submitted to calculation in an unlucky
way, and therefore rejected as false, and finally
returning on the 15th of May and adopting a new line
of attack, stormed the darkness of my mind. So
strong was the support from the combination of my
labour of seventeen years on the observations of
Brahe and the present study, which conspired
together, that at first I believed I was dreaming,
and assuming my conclusion among my basic premises.
But it is absolutely certain and exact that the
proportion between the periodic times of any two
planets is precisely the sesquialterate proportion
of their mean distances." |
— Johannes Kepler; Harmonice
Mundi, The
Harmony of the World
(1619), book V, ch. 3. Trans. E. J. Aiton, A. M.
Duncan and J. V. Field (1997), 411.
|
Kepler was Imperial Mathematician, the most prestigious
appointment in mathematics in Europe
until 1612, when his patron, Emperor Rudolph II was deposed. In Prague Kepler
published a number of important books. In 1604 Astronomia pars
Optica ("The Optical Part of Astronomy") appeared, in which he
treated atmospheric refraction but also treated lenses and gave
the modern explanation of the workings of the eye; in 1606 he
published De Stella Nova ("Concerning the New Star")
on the new
star that had appeared in 1604; and in 1609 his Astronomia Nova
("New Astronomy") appeared, which contained his first two laws
(planets move in elliptical orbits with the sun as one of the
foci, and a planet sweeps out equal areas in equal times).
Whereas other astronomers still followed the ancient precept
that the study of the planets is a problem only in kinematics, Kepler took an openly dynamic approach, introducing physics into
the heavens.
In 1610 Kepler heard and read about Galileo's discoveries with
the spyglass. He quickly composed a long letter of support which
he published as Dissertatio cum Nuncio Sidereo ("Conversation
with the Sidereal Messenger"), and when, later that year, he
obtained the use of a suitable telescope, he published his
observations of Jupiter's satellites under the title Narratio de
Observatis Quatuor Jovis Satellitibus ("Narration about Four
Satellites of Jupiter observed"). These tracts were an enormous
support to Galileo, whose discoveries were doubted or denied by
many. Both of Kepler's tracts were quickly reprinted in
Florence. Kepler went on to provide the beginning of a theory of
the telescope in his Dioptrice, published in 1611.
During this period the Keplers had three children (two had been
born in Graz but died within months), Susanna (1602), who
married Kepler's assistant Jakob Bartsch in 1630, Friedrich
(1604-1611), and Ludwig (1607-1663). Kepler's wife, Barbara,
died in 1612. In that year Kepler accepted the position of
district mathematician in the city of Linz, a position he
occupied until 1626. In Linz Kepler married Susanna Reuttinger.
The couple had six children, of whom three died very early.
In Linz Kepler published first a work on chronology and the year
of Jesus's birth, In German in 1613 and more amply in Latin in
1614: De Vero Anno quo Aeternus Dei Filius Humanam Naturam in
Utero Benedictae Virginis Mariae Assumpsit (Concerning the True
Year in which the Son of God assumed a Human Nature in the
Uterus of the Blessed Virgin Mary"). In this work Kepler
demonstrated that the Christian calendar was in error by five
years, and that Jesus had been born in 4 BC, a conclusion that
is now universally accepted. Between 1617 and 1621 Kepler
published Epitome Astronomiae Copernicanae ("Epitome of
Copernican Astronomy"), which became the most influential
introduction to heliocentric astronomy; in 1619 he published Harmonice Mundi ("Harmony of the World"), in which he derived
the heliocentric distances of the planets and their periods from
considerations of musical harmony. In this work we find his
third law, relating the periods of the planets to their mean
orbital radii.
In 1615-16 there was a witch hunt in Kepler's native region, and
his own mother was accused of being a witch. It was not until
late in 1620 that the proceedings against her ended with her
being set free. At her trial, her defense was conducted by her
son Johannes.
1618 marked the beginning of the Thirty Years War, a war that
devastated the German and Austrian region. Kepler's position in
Linz now became progressively worse, as Counter Reformation
measures put pressure on Protestants in the Upper Austria
province of which Linz was the capital. Because he was a court
official, Kepler was exempted from a decree that banished all
Protestants from the province, but he nevertheless suffered
persecution. During this time Kepler was having his Tabulae
Rudolphinae ("Rudolphine Tables") printed, the new tables, based
on Tycho Brahe's accurate observations, calculated according to
Kepler's elliptical astronomy. When a peasant rebellion broke
out and Linz was besieged, a fire destroyed the printer's house
and shop, and with it much of the printed edition. Soldiers were
garrisoned in Kepler's house. He and his family left Linz in
1626. The Tabulae Rudolphinae were published in Ulm in 1627.
|
Keplar: No
boundaries between art, God and Science |
Kepler lived in an era when there was no
clear distinction between astronomy and astrology, but there was
a strong division between astronomy (a branch of mathematics
within the liberal arts) and physics (a branch of natural
philosophy). Kepler also incorporated religious arguments and
reasoning into his work, motivated by the religious conviction
that God had created the world according to an intelligible plan
that is accessible through the natural light of reason. Kepler's
most important inspiration was a model to explain the relative
distances of the planets from the Sun in the Copernican System.
Johannes Kepler was born in Weil der Stadt in
Swabia, in southwest Germany. His paternal grandfather, Sebald
Kepler, was a respected craftsman who served as mayor of the
city; his maternal grandfather, Melchior Guldenmann, was an
innkeeper and mayor of the nearby village of Eltingen. His
father, Heinrich Kepler, was "an immoral, rough and quarrelsome
soldier," according to Kepler, His father left the family when
Johannes was five years old and is believed to have died in the
Eighty Years' War in the Netherlands. His mother Katharina Guldenmann,
an inn-keeper's daughter, was a healer and herbalist. From 1574
to 1576 Johannes lived with his grandparents; in 1576 his
parents moved to nearby Leonberg, where Johannes entered the
Latin school. In 1584 he entered the Protestant seminary at
Adelberg, and in 1589 he began his university education at the
Protestant university of Tübingen. Here he studied theology and
read widely. He passed the M.A. examination in 1591 and
continued his studies as a graduate student.
 |
This diagram from the Mysterium
Cosmographicum shows the recurrence pattern of the conjunction
of Saturn and Jupiter, a major astrological event. This pattern
led to Kepler's discovery of the nested polyhedra or that
one Platonic solid fits between each pair of the six visible |
At University, Kepler
had learned about Copernicus' system and had immediately
accepted heliocentrism as a real picture of the world:
'I have attested it as true in my deepest soul,'
he
later wrote. Nevertheless, he did not exhibit much
interest in the subject until the day in Gratz when the
figure on the blackboard suggested to him that he could
explain the details of the heliocentric cosmos in terms
of a beautiful underlying geometric pattern. Copernicus
had discovered the general arrangement of the heavens -
the sun at the center and the planets revolving around
it. Now Kepler would explain precisely the orbital sizes
and spacings. That there was a precise mathematical
explanation for the cosmic plan was an article of faith
with Kepler, because for him the world was a reflection
of the supremely Pythagorean God. |
---Wertheim, Pythagoras'
Trousers, 1997 |
Kepler's teacher in the mathematical subjects was Michael
Maestlin (1550-1635). Maestlin was one of the earliest
astronomers to subscribe to Copernicus's heliocentric theory,
although in his university lectures he taught only the Ptolemaic
system. Only in what we might call graduate seminars did he
acquaint his students, among whom was Kepler, with the technical
details of the Copernican system. Kepler stated later that at
this time he became a Copernican for "physical or, if you
prefer, metaphysical reasons."
In 1594 Kepler accepted an appointment as
professor of mathematics and astronomy at the Protestant school at
Graz in Austria, which he took up in April 1594, aged 23. There
were no clear distinctions between astronomy and astrology;
amongst his duties as 'mathematicus' Kepler was expected to
issue an annual almanac of astrological predictions. In his
first almanac he predicted an exceptionally cold winter and a
Turkish incursion into Austria. When both predictions proved
correct, he unexpectedly gained a reputation as a prophet.
On 19th July 1595, a sudden revelation changed
the course of Kepler's life. In preparation for a geometry class
he had drawn a figure on the blackboard of an equilateral
triangle within a circle
with a second circle inscribed within it. He realized that the
ratio of the two circles replicated the ratio of the orbits of
Jupiter and Saturn. In a flash of inspiration, he saw the orbits
of all the planets around the Sun arranged so that regular
geometric figures would fit neatly between them. He tested this
intuition using two-dimensional plane figures — the triangle,
square, pentagon, etc. — but this didn't work. As space is
three-dimensional, he went on to experiment with
three-dimensional geometric solids. Life had taken Kepler
by surprise and ordered he move toward the unknown. For six years, Kepler taught arithmetic,
geometry, Virgil, and rhetoric. In his spare time he pursued his
private studies in astronomy and astrology. In 1597 Kepler
married Barbara Müller. In that same year he published his first
important work, The Cosmographic Mystery, in which he argued
that the distances of the planets from the Sun in the Copernican
system were determined by the five regular solids, if one
supposed that a planet's orbit was circumscribed about one solid
and inscribed in another. Except for Mercury, Kepler's
construction produced remarkably accurate results.
Kepler was the first to state clearly that the
way to understand the motion of the planets was in terms of some
kind of force from the sun. However, in contrast to Galileo,
Kepler thought that a continuous force was necessary to maintain
motion, so he visualized the force from the sun like a rotating
spoke pushing the planet around its orbit.
|
Kepler,
Galileo & Newton |
... retreat before the general ignorance and not
to expose ourselves or heedlessly to oppose the violent attacks
of the mob of scholars and in this you follow Plato and
Pythagoras our true perceptors. But after a tremendous task has
been begun in our time first by Copernicus and then by many very
learned mathematicians and when the assertion that the Earth
moves can no longer be considered something new would it not be
much better to pull the wagon to its goal by our joint efforts
now that we have got it under way and gradually with powerful
voices to shout down the common herd which really does not weigh
the arguments very carefully?
--- Kepler to
Galileo [more]
I wish, my dear Kepler, that we could have a good laugh
together at the extraordinary stupidity of the mob. What
do you think of the foremost philosophers of this
University? In spite of my oft-repeated efforts and
invitations, they have refused, with the obstinacy of a
glutted adder, to look at the planets or Moon or my
telescope. ---Galileo to Kepler
O telescope, instrument of
knowledge, more precious than any sceptre. — Johannes Kepler
Letter to Galileo (1610).
Galileo and
Kepler corresponded and Kepler was among
Galileo's most prominent public defenders, but
while Galileo defended Copernican astronomy he
never wrote about Kepler's model.Galileo may
have been repelled by Kepler's mysticism as he
ridiculed Kepler's correct speculation on tidal
action being influenced by the moon as "occult
phenomena." More likely, Galileo, as a one of
science's greatest self-promoters, was not
inclined to share credit in his field with any
contemporary. |
|
"Among the great men who have philosophized about [the action of
the tides], the one who surprised me most is Kepler. He was a
person of independent genius, [but he] became interested in the
action of the moon on the water, and in other occult phenomena,
and similar childishness.
I wish, my dear Kepler, that we could have a good laugh together
at the extraordinary stupidity of the mob. What do you think of
the foremost philosophers of this University? In spite of my
oft-repeated efforts and invitations, they have refused, with
the obstinacy of a glutted adder, to look at the planets or Moon
or my telescope.
--- Galileo Galilei
|
|

Galileo Galilei (1564-1642)
Galileo's most original contributions to science
were in mechanics where he helped clarify
concepts of acceleration, velocity, and
instantaneous motion. One of the first to record
observations from the recently invented
telescope, was an aggressive popularizer of
Copernican viewpoint and satirist of
Aristotelian physics.
|
|
- "God
wrote the universe in the language of mathematics".
- “I do not feel obliged to
believe that the same God who has endowed us with sense, reason,
and intellect has intended us to forgo their use.”
- “The Bible shows the way to go to
heaven, not the way the heavens go”
- “Where the senses fail us, reason
must step in.”
You cannot teach a man anything; you can only
help him find it within himself.
Measure what is measurable, and make measurable
what is not so.
|
--- Galileo Galilei |
Newton
probably believed, like most alchemists, that he was
rediscovering the lost knowledge of Moses and of Hermes
Trismegistus. These were the legendary sages to whom it
was believed had been revealed divine knowledge. Both
lived in Egypt, where much of their learning had been
preserved in the Great Library of Alexandria, until its
destruction. That knowledge had since been steadily lost
over time; the ancient Greeks had been a 'golden age'
when much of it had still been preserved, but since
their time more and more had been lost. For this reason,
alchemy had become a library-research discipline, not
one given to experiment. Knowledge of the 'hidden arts'
was to be obtained through the discovery and deciphering
of lost and mysterious ancient texts. Newton, of course,
took the opposite tack - although he accepted that he
was rediscovering lost knowledge, he meticulously
checked and noted down his findings by means of chemical
experiment. The brazier in his room burned constantly
for years at a time.
More serious alchemists adopted
codenames for their correspondence. Thus, Newton dubbed
himself Jeova Sanctus Unus - Latin for 'One Holy God',
and simultaneously a nod to Newton's Arian beliefs (that
God was a single, indivisible entity and not a Trinity)
and a near-anagram of his Latinised name, Isaacus
Neuutonus. It was under this moniker that Newton
corresponded with other members of the Hartlib Circle,
including Henry More and Boyle. |
In the beginning of the year 1665 I found the
Method of approximating series & the Rule for reducing any
dignity of any Bionomial into such a series. The same year in
May I found the method of Tangents of Gregory & Slusius, & in
November had the direct method of fluxions & the next year in
January had the Theory of Colours & in May following I had
entrance into ye inverse method of fluxions. And the same year I
began to think of gravity extending to ye orb of the Moon &
(having found out how to estimate the force with wch [a] globe
revolving within a sphere presses the surface of the sphere)
from Keplers rule of the periodic times of the Planets being in sesquialterate proportion of their distances from the center of
their Orbs, I deduced that the forces wch keep the Planets in
their Orbs must [be] reciprocally as the squares of their
distances from the centers about wch they revolve: & thereby
compared the force requisite to keep the Moon in her Orb with
the force of gravity at the surface of the earth, & found them
answer pretty nearly. All this was in the two plague years of
1665-1666. For in those days I was in the prime of my age for
invention & minded Mathematicks & Philosophy more then than at
any time since.
— Sir Isaac Newton
Quoted in Richard Westfall, Never at Rest: A Biography of Isaac
Newton (1980), 143. |
 |
Isaac Newton initiated
classical mechanics in physics. |
Built in part on Kepler's
concept of Sun as center of solar system,
planets move faster near Sun.
Inverse-square law.
Once law known, can use
calculus to drive Kepler's Laws.
Unification Kepler's Laws;
showed their common basis.
|
|
 |
Albert Einstein |
"Imagination is more important than knowledge." |
"But
before mankind could be ripe for a science which takes in the
whole of reality, a second fundamental truth was needed, which
only became common property among philosophers with the advent
of Kepler and Galileo. Pure logical thinking cannot yield us any
knowledge of the empirical world; all knowledge of reality
starts from experience and ends in it. Propositions arrived at
by purely logical means are completely empty as regards reality.
Because Galileo saw this, and particularly because he drummed it
into the scientific world, he is the father of modern physics --
indeed, of modern science altogether."
-Albert Einstein,
Ideas and Opinions "Cosmology -The supreme task of the physicist is to arrive at
those universal elementary laws from which the cosmos can be
built by pure deduction "
'I believe in Spinoza's God who
reveals himself in the orderly harmony of what exists, not in a
God who concerns himself with the fates and actions of human
beings.'
"The release of atom power has changed everything
except our way of thinking...the solution to this problem lies
in the heart of mankind. If only I had known, I should have
become a watchmaker." ---Albert Einstein |
|
|
"The heavenly motions... are nothing but a
continuous song for several voices, perceived not by the ear but
by the intellect,
a figured music which sets landmarks
in the immeasurable flow of time." ---
John Banville: Kepler, (Minerva 1990) |
"It is a vulgar
belief that our astronomical knowledge dates only
from the recent century when it was rescued from the
monks who imprisoned Galileo; but
Hipparchus … who among other achievements
discovered the precession of the eqinoxes, ranks
with the Newtons and the Keplers; and
Copernicus, the modern father of our
celestial science, avows himself, in his famous
work, as only the champion of Pythagoras,
whose system he enforces and illustrates. Even the
most
modish schemes of the day on the origin of things,
which captivate as much by their novelty as their
truth, may find their precursors in ancient sages,
and after a careful analysis of the blended elements
of imagination and induction which charaterise the
new theories, they will be found mainly to rest on
the atom of Epicurus and the monad of
Thales. Scientific, like spiritual truth, has
ever from the beginning been descending from heaven
to man."
|
—
Benjamin Disraeli Lothair (1879),
preface, xvii
|
|
Copernicus and Kepler credit ancients & god for heliocentric
order |
"In the middle of all
sits Sun enthroned. In this most beautiful temple could we place
this luminary in any better position from which he can
illuminate the whole at once? He is rightly called the Lamp, the
Mind, the Ruler of the Universe: Hermes Trismegistus names him
the Visible God, Sophocles' Electra calls him the All-seeing. So
the Sun sits as upon a royal throne ruling his children the
planets which circle round him. The Earth has the Moon at her
service. As Aristotle says, in his On Animals, the Moon has the
closest relationship with the Earth. Meanwhile the Earth
conceives by the Sun, and becomes pregnant with an annual
rebirth" ---Copernicus (De Revolutionibus, Of the Order
of the Heavenly Bodies 10). |
Keplar:
Astronomiae Pars Optica |
Through most of 1603,
Kepler paused his other work to focus on optical theory; the
resulting manuscript, presented to the emperor on January 1,
1604, was published as Astronomiae Pars Optica (The Optical Part
of Astronomy). In it, Kepler described the inverse-square law
governing the intensity of light, reflection by flat and curved
mirrors, and principles of pinhole cameras, as well as the
astronomical implications of optics such as parallax and the
apparent sizes of heavenly bodies. He also extended his study of
optics to the human eye, and is generally considered by
neuroscientists to be the first to recognize that images are
projected inverted and reversed by the eye's lens onto the
retina. The solution to this dilemma was not of particular
importance to Kepler as he did not see it as pertaining to
optics, although he did suggest that the image was later
corrected "in the hollows of the brain" due to the "activity of
the Soul." Today, Astronomiae Pars Optica is generally
recognized as the foundation of modern optics |
Always being subjected to persecution by the
Catholics, Kepler had to relocate several times due to pressure
from the Church, yet he would not convert. Also, mathematicians
were not in great demand at the time, and Kepler did not have
very much money to support his family. He lived in poverty, and
died in poverty, but one thing is for certain, he was very
prolific, and his work did not die with him. |
Astrologer Keplar:
Celestial imprint is the geometric-harmonic imprint
constitutes "the music that impels the listener to dance" |
Kepler believed in astrology in the sense
that he was convinced that planetary configurations physically
imprinted humans at birth with an affinity for a certain
resonance. He
sought a theoretical theory for this intuition.
On the more certain foundations of astrology
(1601). In The Intervening Third Man, or a
warning to theologians, physicians and philosophers
(1610), posing as a third man between the two extreme positions
for and against astrology, Kepler advocated that a definite
relationship between heavenly phenomena and earthly events could
be established.
From his long-term study of weather conditions correlated with
planetary angles and from detailed analysis of his collection of
800 birth charts, Kepler concluded that when planets formed
angles equivalent to particular harmonic ratios a resonance was
set up, both in the archetypal 'Earth-soul' and in the souls of
individuals born under those configurations. He considered
this 'celestial imprint' more important than the traditional
emphasis on signs and houses: "in the vital power of the
human being that is ignited at birth there glows that remembered
image..." The geometric-harmonic imprint constitutes "the
music that impels the listener to dance" as the movements of
the planets, by transit and direction, echo and re-echo the
natal theme. In addition to the Ptolemaic aspects, Kepler
proposed the quintile (72°), bi-quintile (144°) and sesqui-quadrate
(135°). Extending the analogy of the musical scale, the quintile
is equivalent to an interval of a major third (4:5), the sesqui-quadrate
to a minor sixth (5:8) and the bi-quintile to a major sixth
(3:5). |
|
 |
"The chief aim of all investigations of the
external world should be to discover the rational order and
harmony which has been imposed on it by God
and which He revealed to us in the language of mathematics."
"The Earth is round, and is inhabited on all
sides, is insignificantly small, and is borne through the
stars."
"Nature uses as little as possible of
anything."
'Geometry existed before the Creation, is
co-eternal with the mind of God, is God himself ... geometry
provided God with a model for the Creation.' Thus, 'where matter
is, there is geometry.'
"I give myself over to my rapture. I tremble;
my blood leaps. God has waited 6000 years for a looker-on to His
work."
After the birth of printing books became
widespread. Hence everyone throughout Europe devoted himself to
the study of literature... Every year, especially since 1563,
the number of writings published in every field is greater than
all those produced in the past thousand years. Through them
there has today been created a new theology and a new
jurisprudence; the Paracelsians have created medicine anew and
the Copernicans have created astronomy anew. I really believe
that at last the world is alive, indeed seething, and that the
stimuli of these remarkable conjunctions did not act in vain.
“I much prefer the sharpest criticism of a
single intelligent man to the thoughtless approval of the
masses.”
“The diversity of the phenomena of nature
is so great, and the treasures hidden in the heavens so rich,
precisely in order that the human mind shall never be lacking in
fresh nourishment.”
“I demonstrate by means of philosophy that
the earth is round, and is inhabited on all sides; that it is
insignificantly small, and is borne through the stars.”
Planets move in ellipses with the Sun at
one focus.
However, before we come to [special]
creation, which puts an end to all discussion: I think we should
try everything else.
I also ask you my friends not to condemn me
entirely to the mill of mathematical calculations, and allow me
time for philosophical speculations, my only pleasures.
I am stealing the golden vessels of the
Egyptians to build a tabernacle to my God from them, far far
away from the boundaries of Egypt. If you forgive me, I shall
rejoice; if you are enraged with me, I shall bear it. See, I
cast the die, and I write the book. Whether it is to be read by
the people of the present or of the future makes no difference:
let it await its reader for a hundred years, if God himself has
stood ready for six thousand years for one to study him.
— Johannes Kepler
Harmonice Mundi, The Harmony of the World (1619),
Truth is the daughter of time, and I feel
no shame in being her midwife.
"I used to measure the heavens, now I shall
measure the shadows of the Earth. Although my soul was from
heaven, the shadow of my body lies here." - Kepler's epitaph.
|
|
Enlightenment |
Both
the Enlightenment and the people who reacted against it
(Romantics) developed more positive views of wilderness. The
idea that wilderness was good was spreading, but it took several
different forms.
The Enlightenment was an intellectual movement in the 18th
century. The
scientific revolution got people excited that we can
understand the world through science. This led to an emphasis
on finding better ways of doing things, instead of tradition.
This was very influential on the American revolution and the
constitution.
New ways of
seeing nature resulted from the enlightenment, in three rather
contradictory ways.
- the
enlightenment led some intellectuals to
Deism: an
approach to religion that focuses on God as the creator of
the world, rather than emphasizing God intervening in our
daily lives (and if you focus on God as creator then the
creation becomes an important way of knowing God). God is a
perfect watchmaker who made the creation work so well that
God doesn't need to interfere.
- the
development of science led to the idea of
natural theology,
a different approach that lead to the idea that studying
nature was a way to get closer to God, popular even among
some evangelicals
- The
Romantic movement
in Europe was a reaction against the idea that science can
explain everything, that everything is rational. It led to
an enthusiasm for whatever was wild and mysterious. God is
in the mysterious and can't be understood so is a very
personal experience.
|
|
We
warriors of light must be prepared to have patience in difficult
times and to know the Universe is conspiring in our favor, even
though we may not understand how. ---Paulo
Coelho |
"Education is what remains after one
has forgotten everything he learned in school."
-Albert Einstein |
|